Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Victoria Jean Bingham's avatar

'What troubles me is the silent absence of the locals who used to be there... overwhelmingly filled by newcomers from abroad...'

As my young (26) year old son noticed years ago, the problem in America is the absence of cohesivity. What do I mean? The melting pot never worked, and now it's even worse with a flow of people from all over hanging tenaciously onto their own ideas, cultures, languages, resistance to becoming 'part of the pot'. He's done what I did in the 80s' and 90's.. traveled overseas a lot, lived in homogenous communities, and discovered the beauty of one language, one culture, one unit - pulling together as a family..

America was like that in the 20th Century.. even the immigrants learned English and declined to teach their native tongue to their children, so that they could 'assimilate', and become American!. People want to feel like they are part of a unified place a community. That's where empathy and compassion live. They have succeeded in eradicating that in America. The name of the game now is 'discord'. Which is what is helping the rulers to reduce the populations even further, because ... it is unable to band together to resist.

Expand full comment
Luc Lelievre's avatar

In the broader historical context of Québec’s political evolution, it is instructive to recall how a small but determined group of intellectuals and cultural figures such as Gérald Godin and Frère Untel contested the authoritarian hegemony of the Grande Noirceur under Premier Maurice Duplessis. These figures employed literature, journalism, and critical thought to expose and undermine the repressive social order entrenched in politics, religion, and public life during the mid-20th century. Their painstaking efforts to articulate a progressive nationalist vision helped fuel a cultural and political awakening that culminated in the transformative Quiet Revolution of the 1960s, which dismantled old structures and inaugurated a new era of secular governance, expanded social programs, and heightened Québecois identity consciousness. This example serves as an enduring reminder that even deeply institutionalized and culturally hegemonic authoritarian systems remain vulnerable when faced with creative intellectual resistance and collective mobilization. It also highlights the significant role of ideas and cultural work as precursors and enablers of political change, reinforcing the thesis that systemic control and technocratic orders are never immutable but always contingent on active contestation and re-imagination.

Expand full comment
51 more comments...

No posts